Legal Action: National Alliance of Associations, National Trade Business Association, National Transportation Benefits Alliance Association, National Trade Business Alliance of America, Alliance Association Health, Qualified Administrative Specialists of America, American Employers Association, National Alliance Healthcare, Healthcare Alliance, Association Healthcare Management, Inc.; Affinity Health Plans of America, Alliance Health, Affinity Health, Affinity Association Group, National Association of Private Enterprise, Alliance Association Health, National Alliance of Entrepreneurs; Professional Benefits Consultants of Delaware; Professional Benefits Consultants, Inc; PBC Direct; Personal Benefits Consultants, Inc; Thomas J. Sullivan; James Doyle; Christopher Ashiotes; Robert Fortier; Michael B. Roberts and Dawn Maahs

Legal Action: National Alliance of Associations, National Trade Business Association, National Transportation Benefits Alliance Association, National Trade Business Alliance of America, Alliance Association Health, Qualified Administrative Specialists of America, American Employers Association, National Alliance Healthcare, Healthcare Alliance, Association Healthcare Management, Inc.; Affinity Health Plans of America, Alliance Health, Affinity Health, Affinity Association Group, National Association of Private Enterprise, Alliance Association Health, National Alliance of Entrepreneurs; Professional Benefits Consultants of Delaware; Professional Benefits Consultants, Inc; PBC Direct; Personal Benefits Consultants, Inc; Thomas J. Sullivan; James Doyle; Christopher Ashiotes; Robert Fortier; Michael B. Roberts and Dawn Maahs

2015 National Alliance of Associations, National Trade Business Association, National Transportation Benefits Alliance Association, National Trade Business Alliance of America, Alliance Association Health, Qualified Administrative Specialists of America, American Employers Association, National Alliance Healthcare, Healthcare Alliance, Association Healthcare Management, Inc.; Affinity Health Plans of America, Alliance Health, Affinity Health, Affinity Association Group, National Association of Private Enterprise, Alliance Association Health, National Alliance of Entrepreneurs; Professional Benefits Consultants of Delaware; Professional Benefits Consultants, Inc; PBC Direct; Personal Benefits Consultants, Inc; Thomas J. Sullivan; James Doyle; Christopher Ashiotes; Robert Fortier; Michael B. Roberts and Dawn Maahs Consent Agreement and Final Order for James Doyle and Thomas J. Sullivan