SMALL COMPANY OFFERING REGISTRATION (SCOR)
The Small Company Offering Registration (“SCOR”) offers an optional method of registration that utilizes a question-and-answer disclosure document and enables corporations and limited liability companies (LLCs) to raise up to $1 million during a period of up to 12 months through the sales of securities to the public.
The SCOR program streamlines the review process for the company since the review of the offering is coordinated amongst the states in which the company desires to register. A lead review state is appointed to coordinate the review and a single comment letter is generated for all the states participating in the review. The company then works with the lead state to resolve any registration issues, rather than having to deal with each individual state in which the issuer desires to register.
There are several requirements an offering must meet in order to qualify for SCOR registration. The general requirements for conducting a SCOR offering are detailed to the right.
There are many advantages of seeking registration of a securities offering through a SCOR registration.
- The SCOR registration was designed to minimize costs for small businesses seeking to raise capital through a securities offering. The form may be completed electronically and is used as the prospectus in soliciting investors.
- "Merit" standards used by the CSI Securities Division to review these registrations are more relaxed than those applied to larger public offerings.
- SCOR offerings are exempt from registration under federal securities laws by virtue of Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Rule 504 of Regulation D or Section 3(a)(11) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Rule 147 promulgated thereunder.
- Companies may use commissioned selling agents or sell the securities to the public themselves through classified ads or other means of mass solicitation, such as the internet. Investors are not limited as to number or type, nor is there any restriction on the amount that may be sold to any one person.
TYPES OF COMPANIES ELIGIBLE FOR SCOR
All American and Canadian corporations and LLCs may use Form SCOR, with certain exceptions. Specifically, the form may not be used:
- To register securities for resale on behalf of anyone other than the issuer itself
- By partnerships
- By companies in the business of petroleum exploration or production, mining, or in other extractive industries
- By holding companies, portfolio companies, issuers with complex capital structures, commodity pools, equipment leasing programs, or real estate programs
- By "blind pool" offerings (for which the specific business or properties cannot be described)
- If the company, any of the company's management, or 10% or greater stockholders, have had certain regulatory problems in the past
- By any type of company whose securities are subject to registration with a governmental agency other than the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or a state securities regulator. (For example, the securities of banks and other financial institutions are regulated by separate agencies), or
- By public companies that report to the SEC under Sections 12 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
TYPES OF SECURITIES
Form SCOR may be used to register common or preferred stock (including convertible preferred) and options, warrants, or rights, and membership interests in a limited liability company (LLC). If the company can show it will be able to meet debt service based on current earnings, Form SCOR may be used to register debt securities, including convertible debt. Common stock with lesser voting rights than other common shares may not be registered using Form SCOR.
OFFERING SIZE AND PRICE
Up to $1 million may be raised each 12-month period using SCOR. In calculating this limit, sales in all jurisdictions must be included together with any other securities sold under Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Rule 504 or under Section 3(b) of the Securities Act of 1933, or in violation of the registration provisions of federal securities laws. The offering price must be at least $1 per share (for LLCs, $1.00 per unit of interest), and the company may not split its stock or declare stock dividends for two (2) years following effectiveness of the registration, except with the permission of the Securities Administrator or in connection with a subsequent registered public offering.
Securities sold in a SCOR offering are freely transferable. However, because of its small size, a public trading market is unlikely to develop following a SCOR offering. Thus, SCOR offerings are a form of early-stage venture financing, raising funds from investors solicited by means of advertising or other general solicitation, which, if appropriate, may be followed at a later stage by a more conventional public offering that would result in the development of a public trading market for the company's securities.
Financial statements for the company's last fiscal year must be attached to Form SCOR. Financial statements must be prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), complete with appropriate footnote disclosure. They need not be reviewed or audited by an accountant, though audited statements are strongly encouraged, especially if the company lacks qualified accounting knowledge. They also provide added comfort to prospective investors. Further, if you are planning to sell the offering in other states, you will need to comply with their requirements which often include reviewed or audited financial statements.
If you are considering offering in additional states, consult the central website for the CR-SCOR programs, which include CR-SCOR-Mid-Atlantic, CR-SCOR-Midwest, CR-SCOR-New England, and CR-SCOR-Southwest. If you are considering offering on a national basis, check out the Coordinated Review-Equity Program.
Participating StatesStates currently participating in the CR-SCOR-West program include:
- New Mexico
All offers and sales of securities must be registered or exempt from registration under both state and federal securities laws.
Montana SCOR offerings must be registered with the CSI Securities Division by qualification pursuant to MCA 30-10-205.
A company completing the SCOR form will provide answers to questions about:
- The background of persons operating the company (including compensation paid, percentage ownership in the company and any transactions between the individuals and the company)
- Intended uses of the proceeds of the offering
- The terms of the offering and the type of security being offered
- The assets, liabilities and cash flow of the company, and
- Risks associated with investing in the company
Additionally, the Form SCOR requires the company to disclose all other information that is material and necessary for a reasonable person to make an informed investment decision.
The SCOR registration is designed to be exempt from federal registration with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) pursuant to Rule 504 of Regulation D or Section 3(a)(11) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Rule 147 promulgated thereunder.
- Rule 504 is an exemption from federal registration for offerings of securities by non-publicly-held companies in an amount up to $1 million. It permits a company to sell its securities by advertising or other means of general solicitation and does not impose resale restrictions on the securities if the offering is registered at the state level. Currently, the SEC does not review offerings made pursuant to Rule 504.
- Section 3(a)(11) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Rule 147 promulgated thereunder provide an exemption from federal registration for offers and sales of securities in any amount, but all securities must be offered and sold to residents of a single state. Rule 147 provides that issuers relying on Section 3(a)(11) must also reside and conduct business in the state where securities are to be offered for sale. Corporations and limited partnerships are considered residents of the state in which they are incorporated or organized. An issuer is deemed to be doing business in a state if it derived at least 80% of its gross revenues and those of its subsidiaries from such state, at least 80% of its assets are located in such state, the issuer uses at least 80% of the net proceeds of the offering for business purposes in such state, and the principal office of the issuer is located in such state.
The core of the SCOR registration is the Form SCOR (Form Score) Disclosure Document, Form U-7, which is presented in an easily understandable question-and-answer format.
The form is designed for use by small and emerging businesses whose principals may prepare the form themselves without the expertise of attorneys and accountants experienced in securities laws.
The questions presented in the form are designed to elicit specific types of information of special relevance to small businesses. These requests for information are more detailed than on general registration forms, so that persons using Form SCOR can more easily understand what information is being sought. Because a registration is involved, coordinated review team will comment on the disclosure provided and may request more detailed disclosure if the answers are not sufficiently responsive.
Remember, investors will receive the Form SCOR and therefore an answer of "No" or "Inapplicable" may itself convey information about the offering to the investor. The form contains a number of notes directed to investors, indicating how they may use or interpret answers to certain questions. This approach is unique to Form SCOR and enhances disclosure to investors.
Another unusual aspect of the form is that its questions present issues that a small business should address to become successful. Thus, in providing satisfactory answers, a company is compelled to detail its business plan describing, systematically, its anticipated steps to success. If the form is filled out properly, the assumptions and weaknesses in the plan should be evident, and these should be prominently disclosed in the order of their importance as risk factors in the offering.
Because of the restrictions on the use of Form SCOR and the nature of the capital structure of small businesses, the CSI Securities Division has relaxed certain of the tough merit review standards it usually imposes on registered offerings. One of the merit standards that is applied is a modified version of the state's promotional stock rules.
The formula for determining "promotional shares" is complex. From those shares issued to founders, management, or major owners of the corporation, a determination is made of those deemed "fully paid" shares. This is determined by dividing the amount of consideration paid in past purchases of the shares by 85% of the proposed public offering price in the offering. Tangible property used as payment in past purchases is counted at its fair value, if that is readily and objectively ascertainable.
As applied to SCOR offerings, there may be an unlimited number of promotional shares. However, those in excess of 60% of the shares to be outstanding after the offering must be escrowed for a certain period of time, usually four (4) years, or until the company satisfies other release provisions in the escrow agreement. In lieu of an escrow, the company may enter into a lock-in agreement that does not involve the expense of a third-party escrow agent. Shares held in escrow or lock-in are still outstanding and may be voted by their owners to retain control. All dividends and other distributions upon securities held in escrow, and any substitute securities or property received upon any merger or reorganization, must also be placed in escrow.
The overwhelming majority of SCOR offerings are sold directly by the company. These offerings are frequently called "self-underwritten" offerings or "direct public offerings" (DPOs). Mass solicitation may be used, including public meetings, advertisements, and the internet. Any type of investor may purchase any amount in the offering.
Commissioned selling agents or finders may also be used. Past regulatory problems by potential selling agents in the offering, the selling agents' management, or 10% or greater owners may result in the disqualification of the selling agents. Selling agents must sell only on behalf of the company and not on their own behalf. Accordingly, firmly underwritten offerings are prohibited.
A selling agent or finder engaged in the business of selling securities must be registered as a Broker-Dealer with the CSI. Individuals receiving commissions or other compensation for selling securities in the offering must be registered as securities salespersons and have passed appropriate examinations.
Officers and directors of the company may be exempt from registration. Please check with an attorney to determine the registration requirements for such persons.
Proceeds of the offering must be placed in an impound with an independent bank or similar institution until the minimum amount necessary for the company to achieve its stated objectives is raised. The company may raise additional funds so long as their anticipated use is clearly disclosed.
Company personnel can prepare the information requested on the Form SCOR and file the appropriate documents with the CSI Securities Division. Remember, it is often beneficial for the company to seek the assistance of counsel experienced in securities law issues. Although assistance of experienced counsel adds a transactional cost to the company for the offering, the dollars invested may return important dividends in terms of more timely resolution of regulatory issues and achievement of an earlier offering date than would be the case without the assistance of experienced counsel.
The purpose of this document is to acquaint the small businessperson with the possibility of raising capital through a SCOR offering. It should not be relied upon to actually make a securities offering. There are many additional important issues, of which a person making a securities offering should be aware. This document summarizes only some of the issues involved in conducting a SCOR offering.
- CSI SECURITIES DIVISION—For more information, please contact us at 800.332.6148 or 406.444.2040. The CSI Securities Division has many informational materials available to aid the small businessperson in evaluating the possibility of conducting a securities offering in Montana. The agencies listed below may also provide useful information.
- MONTANA SECRETARY OF STATE—For more information on incorporating your business in Montana.
- MONTANA SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT CENTERS (SBDC)—Montana Department of Commerce provides assistance to small businesses in Montana.
- SCORE—A nonprofit organization of retired businesspeople that often operates programs to assist entrepreneurs. Location of chapters around the state usually can be found in the white pages of the telephone directory.
- U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION—May be able to provide assistance to the entrepreneur. Regional offices are in Helena and Billings.